Investment in early childhood development has been recognized as an effective strategy to improve long-term educational, health, and economic outcomes in children across the world.1,2  As such, research supporting the design of evidence-based sustainable early childhood development programs and public policies is critical. In this issue of Pediatrics, Grantham-McGregor et al3  report on a cluster randomized control trial in which the effectiveness of an early childhood development intervention in Odisha, India, was examined. Following a protocol previously adapted from the Reach Up and Learn program,4  the study authors aimed to compare 2 models for delivering the intervention: mother-child group sessions (GS) and home visiting (HV).

In the intervention, researchers sought to support positive parent-child interactions through play. In addition, because of the high prevalence of poor nutrition in this community,4  nutritional education (NE) focused on the child’s diet, and family hygiene practices were also included within the study arms. In this study, 192 villages in Odisha were randomly assigned to 1 of 4 groups: (1) control (not receiving any intervention), (2) NE (40-minute individual home visits), (3) NE + HV (60-minute individual home visits), and (4) NE + GS (90-minute mother-child GS). For 24 months, trained facilitators from the community conducted weekly NE, HV, and GS. Sessions consisted of demonstrations of play and interaction strategies by using homemade toys and books, which mothers could use at home and exchange in the next session. NE included cooking demonstrations. Of 1449 mothers with children 7 to 16 months old who were enrolled, ∼1300 provided data on child cognitive and physical health indicators at baseline and in follow-up assessments conducted 12 and 24 months after the programs started.

Intention-to-treat analyses from this study revealed that children in the NE + HV and in the NE + GS groups had higher scores in cognition and language in the first year of the intervention compared with those in the NE and control groups, with benefits sustained into the second year. There were no detectable differences between the HV and GS groups.

There are 3 important implications of this study for the sustainability of community early childhood development interventions in low- and middle-income countries. First, comparable results were found for the HV and GS groups. This is important because each model has its own strengths and challenges. In GS, parents have the opportunity to learn play and reading strategies by observing and sharing experiences with other families, which may be particularly important in contexts in which families may experience social isolation.5,6  However, GS require significant coordination across families related to time and location. Alternatively, HV addresses challenges related to coordination and comfort and may provide an opportunity to tailor the intervention on the basis of the child and the family’s characteristics,4,7,8  but it usually demands more personnel and time.

Second, comparable effects for GS and HV were observed despite significantly lower attendance in GS. Lack of attendance in parenting programs is a recognized barrier, especially in low-income communities.9,10  One approach to addressing this barrier is situating programs in platforms in which families are already present (eg, health care and child educational settings).1118  For example, a cluster randomized control trial of a community-based group model in educational child care centers in Brazil demonstrated good attendance with positive impacts on cognitive stimulation and child development.18,19 

Third, GS delivered comparable results despite costs that were one-quarter that of HV (GS = $29 versus HV = $123 per child per year). Previous research has indicated that groups can cost significantly less than individualized approaches,20  primarily because one facilitator can deliver the intervention to many families in one session. Even so, consistent with other research in low- and middle-income countries,18,21  both approaches resulted in relatively low costs by using community personnel and resources as well as processes for exchange of play materials as an alternative to purchasing.

Another finding was that the provision of NE alone had no benefit for child cognitive development or physical growth. This is consistent with other studies revealing that NE or supplements may not result in improved cognitive development, whereas interventions focused on cognitive stimulation have consistently revealed developmental benefits.22,23  The authors note that nutrition supplementation might be needed in addition to education to address growth and that broader improvements within the community (eg, sanitation) may also be required.22,2426 

Coronavirus disease 2019 has added new challenges for delivering early childhood development prevention programs. In higher income countries, there have been significant efforts to address these challenges through remote adaptations, including in health care (eg, Reach Out and Read,27  Video Interaction Project,28  HealthySteps29 ) and through HV30  (eg, Nurse-Family Partnership,31  Family Connects,32  Parents as Teachers33 ). Although low- and middle-income countries may have barriers to remote delivery related to access to devices and data,34  studies suggest potential for positive impacts.3539  Adaptation of early childhood development prevention programs for remote delivery in lower middle-income countries represents an urgent need given the high likelihood of developmental morbidity resulting from the pandemic.4048 

In summary, this study contributes significantly to the evidence base regarding early childhood development program implementation, optimization, and sustainability in low- and middle-income countries.2,49  Findings suggest that both GS and HV models can be used to effectively deliver early childhood development interventions, suggesting that there is a range of effective approaches to choose from. Although HV may present fewer barriers to attendance and/or engagement, GS may result in comparable impact at lower costs. Communities can therefore make decisions regarding platforms for implementation of early childhood development programs on the basis of their individual resources and needs.

Opinions expressed in these commentaries are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the American Academy of Pediatrics or its Committees.

FUNDING: No external funding.

COMPANION PAPER: A companion to this article can be found online at www.pediatrics.org/cgi/doi/10.1542/peds.2020-002725.

GS

group sessions

HV

home visiting

NE

nutritional education

1
Heckman
JJ
.
Invest in early childhood development: reduce deficits, strengthen the economy. 2012. Available at: https://heckmanequation.org/www/assets/2013/07/F_HeckmanDeficitPieceCUSTOM-Generic_052714-3-1.pdf. Accessed August 30, 2020
2
Richter
LM
,
Daelmans
B
,
Lombardi
J
, et al.;
Paper 3 Working Group and the Lancet Early Childhood Development Series Steering Committee
.
Investing in the foundation of sustainable development: pathways to scale up for early childhood development
.
Lancet
.
2017
;
389
(
10064
):
103
118
3
Grantham-McGregor
S
,
Adya
A
,
Attanasio
O
, et al
.
Group sessions or home visits for early childhood development in India: a cluster RCT
.
Pediatrics
.
2020
;
146
(
6
):
e2020002725
4
Grantham-McGregor
S
,
Smith
JA
.
Extending the Jamaican early childhood development intervention
.
J Appl Res Child
.
2016
;
7
(
2
):
4
5
Canfield
CF
,
Seery
A
,
Weisleder
A
, et al
.
Encouraging parent–child book sharing: potential additive benefits of literacy promotion in health care and the community
.
Early Child Res Q
.
2020
;
50
(
pt 1
):
221
229
6
Fernald
LCH
,
Kagawa
RMC
,
Knauer
HA
,
Schnaas
L
,
Guerra
AG
,
Neufeld
LM
.
Promoting child development through group-based parent support within a cash transfer program: experimental effects on children’s outcomes
.
Dev Psychol
.
2017
;
53
(
2
):
222
236
7
Vazir
S
,
Engle
P
,
Balakrishna
N
, et al
.
Cluster-randomized trial on complementary and responsive feeding education to caregivers found improved dietary intake, growth and development among rural Indian toddlers
.
Matern Child Nutr
.
2013
;
9
(
1
):
99
117
8
Andrew
A
,
Attanasio
O
,
Augsburg
B
, et al
.
Effects of a scalable home-visiting intervention on child development in slums of urban India: evidence from a randomised controlled trial
.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry
.
2020
;
61
(
6
):
644
652
9
Heinrichs
N
,
Bertram
H
,
Kuschel
A
,
Hahlweg
K
.
Parent recruitment and retention in a universal prevention program for child behavior and emotional problems: barriers to research and program participation
.
Prev Sci
.
2005
;
6
(
4
):
275
286
10
Baker
CN
,
Arnold
DH
,
Meagher
S
.
Enrollment and attendance in a parent training prevention program for conduct problems
.
Prev Sci
.
2011
;
12
(
2
):
126
138
11
Chang
SM
,
Grantham-McGregor
SM
,
Powell
CA
, et al
.
Integrating a parenting intervention with routine primary health care: a cluster randomized trial
.
Pediatrics
.
2015
;
136
(
2
):
272
280
12
Mendelsohn
AL
,
Huberman
HS
,
Berkule
SB
,
Brockmeyer
CA
,
Morrow
LM
,
Dreyer
BP
.
Primary care strategies for promoting parent-child interactions and school readiness in at-risk families: the Bellevue Project for Early Language, Literacy, and Education Success
.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med
.
2011
;
165
(
1
):
33
41
13
Singla
DR
,
Kumbakumba
E
,
Aboud
FE
.
Effects of a parenting intervention to address maternal psychological wellbeing and child development and growth in rural Uganda: a community-based, cluster randomised trial
.
Lancet Glob Health
.
2015
;
3
(
8
):
e458
e469
14
Ertem
IO
,
Atay
G
,
Bingoler
BE
,
Dogan
DG
,
Bayhan
A
,
Sarica
D
.
Promoting child development at sick-child visits: a controlled trial
.
Pediatrics
.
2006
;
118
(
1
).
15
Messito
MJ
,
Mendelsohn
AL
,
Katzow
MW
,
Scott
MA
,
Vandyousefi
S
,
Gross
RS
.
Prenatal and pediatric primary care-based child obesity prevention program: a randomized trial
.
Pediatrics
.
2020
;
146
(
4
):
e20200709
16
Klass
P
,
Dreyer
BP
,
Mendelsohn
AL
.
Reach out and read: literacy promotion in pediatric primary care
.
Adv Pediatr
.
2009
;
56
(
1
):
11
27
17
Walker
SP
,
Powell
C
,
Chang-Lopez
SM
, et al
.
Delivering parenting interventions through health services in the Caribbean.
2015
. Available at: https://publications.iadb.org/handle/11319/7305. Accessed September 14, 2020
18
Weisleder
A
,
Mazzuchelli
DSR
,
Lopez
AS
, et al
.
Reading aloud and child development: a cluster-randomized trial in Brazil
.
Pediatrics
.
2018
;
141
(
1
):
e20170723
19
Mendelsohn
AL
,
da Rosa Piccolo
L
,
Oliveira
JBA
, et al
.
RCT of a reading aloud intervention in Brazil: do impacts differ depending on parent literacy?
Early Child Res Q
.
2020
;
53
(
4
):
601
611
20
Cunningham
CE
,
Bremner
R
,
Boyle
M
.
Large group community-based parenting programs for families of preschoolers at risk for disruptive behaviour disorders: utilization, cost effectiveness, and outcome
.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry
.
1995
;
36
(
7
):
1141
1159
21
Knauer
HA
,
Jakiela
P
,
Ozier
O
,
Aboud
F
,
Fernald
LCH
.
Enhancing young children’s language acquisition through parent–child book-sharing: a randomized trial in rural Kenya
.
Early Child Res Q
.
2020
;
50
(
pt 1
):
179
190
22
Hossain
M
,
Choudhury
N
,
Adib Binte Abdullah
K
, et al
.
Evidence-based approaches to childhood stunting in low and middle income countries: a systematic review
.
Arch Dis Child
.
2017
;
102
(
10
):
903
909
23
Grantham-McGregor
SM
,
Fernald
LCH
,
Kagawa
RMC
,
Walker
S
.
Effects of integrated child development and nutrition interventions on child development and nutritional status
.
Ann N Y Acad Sci
.
2014
;
1308
:
11
32
24
Bhutta
ZA
,
Das
JK
,
Rizvi
A
, et al.;
Lancet Nutrition Interventions Review Group, the Maternal and Child Nutrition Study Group
.
Evidence-based interventions for improvement of maternal and child nutrition: what can be done and at what cost?
Lancet
.
2013
;
382
(
9890
):
452
477
25
Muhoozi
GKM
,
Atukunda
P
,
Diep
LM
, et al
.
Nutrition, hygiene, and stimulation education to improve growth, cognitive, language, and motor development among infants in Uganda: a cluster-randomized trial
.
Matern Child Nutr
.
2018
;
14
(
2
):
e12527
26
Grantham-McGregor
SM
,
Cumper
G
.
Jamaican studies in nutrition and child development, and their implications for national development
.
Proc Nutr Soc
.
1992
;
51
(
1
):
71
79
27
Reach Out and Read
.
Translating Reach Out and Read to Telehealth. Available at: https://www.reachoutandread.org/what-we-do/telehealth/. Accessed September 17, 2020
28
Video Interaction Project
.
Available at: https://www.videointeractionproject.org/. Accessed September 17, 2020
29
HealthySteps
.
Telehealth and remote service delivery resources amid COVID-19. Available at: https://www.healthysteps.org/article/telehealth-and-remote-service-delivery-resources-amid-covid-19-162. Accessed September 21, 2020
30
Institute for the Advancement of Family Support Professionals
.
Rapid response: virtual home visiting. Available at: https://rrvhv.earlyimpactva.org/. Accessed September 21, 2020
31
Nurse-Family Partnership
.
Flexibility and resilience: our response to COVID-19. Available at: https://www.nursefamilypartnership.org/covid-19/. Accessed September 21, 2020
32
Family Connects International
.
Our stories. Available at: https://familyconnects.org/our-stories/. Accessed September 21, 2020
33
Parents as Teachers National Center
.
Virtual service delivery. Available at: https://parentsasteachers.org/virtual-service-delivery. Accessed September 21, 2020
34
Combi
C
,
Pozzani
G
,
Pozzi
G
.
Telemedicine for developing countries. A survey and some design issues
.
Appl Clin Inform
.
2016
;
7
(
4
):
1025
1050
35
Merchant
R
,
Torous
J
,
Rodriguez-Villa
E
,
Naslund
JA
.
Digital technology for management of severe mental disorders in low-income and middle-income countries
.
Curr Opin Psychiatry
.
2020
;
33
(
5
):
501
507
36
The World Bank
.
How text messages helped parents in rural Ecuador improve their children’s health. 2019. Available at: https://www.worldbank.org/en/results/2019/06/24/how-text-messages-helped-parents-in-rural-ecuador-improve-their-childrens-health. Accessed September 17, 2020
37
Ubongo. Annual report
2019
. Available at: https://www.ubongo.org/wp-content/uploads/2019-Ubongo-Annual-Report.pdf. Accessed September 17, 2020
38
Education Development Center
. Radio Instruction to Strengthen Education (RISE) and Zanzibar Teacher Upgrading by Radio (ZTUR): Post-Project Evaluation in Zanzibar. Final Report. Washington, DC: US Agency for International Development Education in Crisis and Conflict Network;
2015
39
Mueller
S
,
Soriano
D
,
Boscor
A
, et al
.
MANTRA: development and localization of a mobile educational health game targeting low literacy players in low and middle income countries
.
BMC Public Health
.
2020
;
20
(
1
):
1171
40
Brown
SM
,
Doom
JR
,
Lechuga-Peña
S
,
Watamura
SE
,
Koppels
T
.
Stress and parenting during the global COVID-19 pandemic [published online ahead of print August 20, 2020]
.
Child Abuse Negl
.
2020
;
104699
. doi:
41
Kim
H
,
Park
KJ
,
Shin
YW
, et al
.
Psychological impact of quarantine on caregivers at a children’s hospital for contact with case of COVID-19
.
J Korean Med Sci
.
2020
;
35
(
28
):
e255
42
Russell
BS
,
Hutchison
M
,
Tambling
R
,
Tomkunas
AJ
,
Horton
AL
.
Initial challenges of caregiving during COVID-19: caregiver burden, mental health, and the parent-child relationship
.
Child Psychiatry Hum Dev
.
2020
;
51
(
5
):
671
682
43
Moore
SA
,
Faulkner
G
,
Rhodes
RE
, et al
.
Impact of the COVID-19 virus outbreak on movement and play behaviours of Canadian children and youth: a national survey
.
Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act
.
2020
;
17
(
1
):
85
44
Spinelli
M
,
Lionetti
F
,
Pastore
M
,
Fasolo
M
.
Parents’ stress and children’s psychological problems in families facing the COVID-19 outbreak in Italy
.
Front Psychol
.
2020
;
11
:
1713
45
Pisano
L
,
Galimi
D
,
Cerniglia
L
.
A qualitative report on exploratory data on the possible emotional/behavioral correlates of Covid-19 lockdown in 4-10 years children in Italy [preprint published online April 13, 2020]
.
PsyArXiv
. doi:
46
Jiao
WY
,
Wang
LN
,
Liu
J
, et al
.
Behavioral and emotional disorders in children during the COVID-19 epidemic
.
J Pediatr
.
2020
;
221
:
264
266.e1
47
Duan
L
,
Shao
X
,
Wang
Y
, et al
.
An investigation of mental health status of children and adolescents in China during the outbreak of COVID-19
.
J Affect Disord
.
2020
;
275
:
112
118
48
Saurabh
K
,
Ranjan
S
.
Compliance and psychological impact of quarantine in children and adolescents due to covid-19 pandemic
.
Indian J Pediatr
.
2020
;
87
(
7
):
532
536
49
Walker
SP
,
Wachs
TD
,
Grantham-McGregor
S
, et al
.
Inequality in early childhood: risk and protective factors for early child development
.
Lancet
.
2011
;
378
(
9799
):
1325
1338

Competing Interests

POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST: The authors have indicated they have no potential conflicts of interest to disclose.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.